The evolution of ultraconserved elements in vertebrates

Despite first being described twenty years ago, Ultraconserved elements (UCEs) have remained something of a mystery. In this paper, we make use of a new, efficient tool for de novo prediction of UCEs from multiple genomes, dedUCE, to analyse the growing number of mammalian genomes. Based on this analysis, we propose a revised definition for UCEs, and investigate their evolution.

Cummins M, Watson C, Edwards RJ & Mattick JS (2024): The evolution of ultraconserved elements in vertebrates. Mol Biol Evol 41(7):msae146. [Mol Biol Evol] [PubMed]

Abstract

Ultraconserved elements were discovered two decades ago, arbitrarily defined as sequences that are identical over a length ≥ 200 bp in the human, mouse, and rat genomes. The definition was subsequently extended to sequences ≥ 100 bp identical in at least three of five mammalian genomes (including dog and cow), and shown to have undergone rapid expansion from ancestors in fish and strong negative selection in birds and mammals. Since then, many more genomes have become available, allowing better definition and more thorough examination of ultraconserved element distribution and evolutionary history. We developed a fast and flexible analytical pipeline for identifying ultraconserved elements in multiple genomes, dedUCE, which allows manipulation of minimum length, sequence identity, and number of species with a detectable ultraconserved element according to specified parameters. We suggest an updated definition of ultraconserved elements as sequences ≥ 100 bp and ≥97% sequence identity in ≥50% of placental mammal orders (12,813 ultraconserved elements). By mapping ultraconserved elements to ∼200 species, we find that placental ultraconserved elements appeared early in vertebrate evolution, well before land colonization, suggesting that the evolutionary pressures driving ultraconserved element selection were present in aquatic environments in the Cambrian–Devonian periods. Most (>90%) ultraconserved elements likely appeared after the divergence of gnathostomes from jawless predecessors, were largely established in sequence identity by early Sarcopterygii evolution—before the divergence of lobe-finned fishes from tetrapods—and became near fixed in the amniotes. Ultraconserved elements are mainly located in the introns of protein-coding and noncoding genes involved in neurological and skeletomuscular development, enriched in regulatory elements, and dynamically expressed throughout embryonic development.